Rebuy vs ReConvert: Which Is Better for Shopify Stores?

Some links below are affiliate links. If you sign up through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a pick.

For most small and mid-size Shopify stores, ReConvert (renamed Upsell.com in April 2026) is the better pick: all features are included on every tier, the price is published, and paid plans start at $9.99/month. Rebuy fits larger brands that want a smart cart, search, bundles and automated flows from one vendor, and that are ready to talk to sales about package pricing.

Quick comparison

	ReConvert (Upsell.com)	Rebuy
Free option	Free up to 50 orders or $50 upsell revenue (App Store listing)	Rebuy Monetize: free, pays you for thank-you and post-purchase offers
Paid pricing	$9.99, $19.99, $39.99/mo by orders or upsell revenue (listing)	From $25/mo for one package; scales with monthly orders
What scales the price	Store orders or upsell revenue, whichever is higher	Monthly orders and number of packages
Feature gating	All features on every tier	Bought as four separate packages
Main placements	Product, cart, checkout, post-purchase, thank-you	Smart cart, widgets, bundles, post-purchase, search, flows
Checkout upsells	Shopify Plus	Checkout extensions are Shopify Plus only
Trial	14 days, once per store	Rebuy's pages conflict; confirm with Rebuy
Shopify App Store	4.8 (3,129 reviews)*	Listing says not currently available

*As listed on the Shopify App Store in November 2026.

Two different kinds of product

ReConvert is an upsell app. Its listing ("ReConvert Post Purchase Upsell") places offers on product, cart, checkout, post-purchase and thank-you pages, with quantity breaks, upsell pop-ups, bundles, AI product recommendations, AI-built upsells and cross-sells, A/B testing, analytics and segmentation. It also supports Wix.

Rebuy calls itself a personalization engine. Upsells are one part of four packages:

Cart & Merchandising: Smart Cart, merchandising widgets, dynamic bundles and a bundle builder
Checkout & Post-Purchase: checkout extensions (Shopify Plus only) and post-purchase offers
Search & Collections: Smart Search and Smart Collections
Flows & A/B Testing: Smart Flows, A/B testing and landing pages

If you only want post-purchase and thank-you page upsells, ReConvert covers that in one app. If you want to rebuild your cart drawer, on-site search and collection sorting as well, Rebuy covers more ground.

Pricing

ReConvert, on the Shopify App Store listing:

Free: up to 50 orders or $50 upsell revenue
$9.99/month: 51–100 store orders or upsell revenue
$19.99/month: 101–200
$39.99/month: 201–500

After the trial, you are billed on whichever is higher over the last 30 days: total store orders or the revenue Upsell.com generated. Upsell.com's help center states, "Every feature is included on every plan. Tiers differ by volume and support."

Watch out: the help center lists a different tier set from the listing: Growth free for eligible stores up to 2,000, Scale from $199 (up to 10,000), Elite from $499 (up to 20,000) and Enterprise custom. The two official sources disagree, so confirm the price shown when you install. The help center also mentions a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Rebuy, on its pricing page:

From $25/month for one package, priced by monthly Shopify orders (the calculator runs from 250 to 50,000 orders)
10% off two packages, 20% off three, 30% off all four
10% off for annual billing
Premium Support: $499/month for priority handling, a customer success manager and quarterly business reviews
Platform One: all packages plus Monetize and Premium Support, price by contact
A money-back guarantee with refund requests due within 60 days of the Shopify invoice, and a stated positive-ROI guarantee

Watch out: per-package prices above the $25 starting point appear only as placeholders on the page, so you need the calculator or sales to get your number.

What it costs at two store sizes

Listed prices only.

150 orders a month, under $150 upsell revenue:

ReConvert: $19.99/month (101–200 tier on the listing)
Rebuy: from $25/month for one package; the exact price at 150 orders isn't published

2,000 orders a month:

ReConvert: the listing's tiers stop at 500; the help center's Growth tier is free up to 2,000. Confirm at install.
Rebuy: not published. Use the calculator for your order tier, then apply package and annual discounts.

At small sizes, ReConvert is clearly cheaper and easier to price. At larger sizes, neither publishes a number you can rely on without checking, so get both quotes.

Earning from thank-you page offers

Rebuy Monetize is free and included in every plan. Rebuy pays you monthly for showing offers on thank-you and post-purchase pages; its pricing page describes earnings of "$.20-.35+" per transaction. Our fact sheet notes this is limited to US and Canada customers. ReConvert's listing doesn't describe a comparable paid-offer program.

Edge: Rebuy, if you are open to showing third-party offers after purchase.

Availability on Shopify

ReConvert is on the Shopify App Store with a 4.8 rating from 3,129 reviews, as listed on the Shopify App Store in November 2026.

Rebuy's App Store page currently says, "This app is not currently available on the Shopify App Store," and directs support questions to Rebuy. If you are considering Rebuy, ask them how to install before planning around it.

Integrations

ReConvert's listing names Shopify Flow, Ali Reviews, Klaviyo, Loox and Stamped, and it works with Shopify Subscriptions. Rebuy's packages center on its own cart, search and flows; its pricing page doesn't list third-party integrations.

Testing, analytics and support

ReConvert lists A/B testing, a full upselling funnel, advanced analytics and segmentation, and 24/7 live chat support on every tier. Rebuy puts A/B testing, Smart Flows and landing pages in its separate Flows & A/B Testing package, so testing is an extra purchase unless you buy that package. Rebuy's higher-touch help is Premium Support at $499/month, which adds a customer success manager and quarterly business reviews.

Edge: ReConvert, if you want testing and support included in the base price.

Watch outs for each

ReConvert: the App Store listing and help center show different tiers, billing uses orders or upsell revenue (whichever is higher), and checkout upsells need Shopify Plus.
Rebuy: most package prices aren't published, checkout extensions need Shopify Plus, its pages conflict on trial length, and the App Store page says it is not currently available there.

Who should choose ReConvert

Stores under a few hundred orders a month that want a low, published price.
Stores that want post-purchase, thank-you and product page offers without choosing packages.
Stores that may also run on Wix.

Who should choose Rebuy

Larger brands that want a smart cart, bundles, search and automated flows from one vendor.
Shopify Plus stores that want checkout extensions alongside on-site personalization.
Brands that can budget for Premium Support or a Platform One contract.

Which one should you choose?

Choose ReConvert if you want every feature on every tier at a published price, and your main goal is upsells around the purchase.
Choose Rebuy if you are replacing your cart, search and merchandising too, and you are big enough that a sales-led price makes sense.
Comparing more options? Our best upsell apps for Shopify roundup adds Aftersell, Zipify OCU and Frequently Bought Together.

Common questions

Is ReConvert the same as Upsell.com? Yes. ReConvert announced its rename to Upsell.com in April 2026. The Shopify listing is still titled "ReConvert Post Purchase Upsell."

Is Rebuy more expensive than ReConvert? At small volumes, yes. ReConvert's paid tiers start at $9.99/month and include all features. Rebuy starts at $25/month for a single package, and most package prices beyond that aren't published.

Do I need Shopify Plus for either app? Only for in-checkout offers. Rebuy's checkout extensions and ReConvert's checkout upsells both require Shopify Plus. Post-purchase and thank-you page offers don't.

Can I install Rebuy from the Shopify App Store? Its App Store page currently says it is not available there. Contact Rebuy directly about installation.

How we put this together

We did not test either app hands-on. Prices and features come from ReConvert's Shopify App Store listing and Upsell.com's pricing help article, and from Rebuy's pricing page and Shopify App Store page, all read in November 2026, plus our fact sheets built from those vendors' official pages. The ReConvert rating is as listed on the Shopify App Store in November 2026. Both apps' pricing depends on your volume, so confirm current terms before you install.

Rebuy vs ReConvert: Which Upsell App Fits Your Shopify Store?